
It’s easy to be in awe of powerful speakers, but many of us fall short of our preaching heroes. That’s okay. As preachers, we’re commanded to preach the Word to the best of our ability. The problems only appear when we fail to do that.
Still, some bad habits inevitably creep in. Here are 9 DONT’S to keep in mind if you don’t want to preach lousy sermons.
1. DON’T come to the pulpit unprepared – There are times when we have a particularly stressful week. Two funerals and a wedding fall all together, and you’re left scrambling for Sunday. (For these occasions, I like to keep a handful of standalone sermons ready to go). These weeks are rare, but unavoidable when they do come. What is avoidable is those merely “busy” weeks when we still seem to come up short.
For those privileged enough to present the Word of God each Sunday, it is one of the highest duties God can give. We shouldn’t betray that duty by cutting corners. Don’t be lazy when it comes to developing your outline. Don’t eisegete your text to fit your pet peeves. Don’t use the same 5 references week after week. Don’t preach the book you’re reading. Use resources, but do your own work. Ministering the word is too important to fall through the cracks.
2. DON’T show off your extensive knowledge – The best compliment I ever received sounded like an insult, “I love that your preaching is so simple. You never say anything complicated!”
Many pastors feel the need to prove themselves, so they make a big deal of their education and knowledge. They include all sorts of tidbits about the background that they find interesting, all the while forgetting that what interests them may not necessarily carry the same captivation for their congregation.
The moment we forget our audience is the moment that we miss the mark in our preaching. Certainly, not every audience is the same. An urban church in the shadow of an ivy league school might require more book knowledge than a rural church where most have only a high school education. We should tailor our teaching to the average level of our audience.
This doesn’t mean we shouldn’t prepare. A pastor should know the meaning of the greek and the chiastic structure of a passage, but that doesn’t mean every detail needs to be articulated in every sermon. It doesn’t. Too many details distract from the main points of the sermon, and it reinforces the notion that Bible Study is better left to the professionals. Keep your sermons simple.
3. DON’T start by telling them why they shouldn’t listen – You’ve heard it before: “This was a really difficult passage”, “I had a cold this week, so this is the best I could do”, “I had a hard time figuring out what to talk about this week”, etc.
Yes, we will have times where we didn’t feel we adequately prepared. Yes, we will have times that we’re not sure we understood every nuance of the passage (or any nuance in a passage!). And yes, we have those weeks where we don’t feel good, so we’re not confident. But we shouldn’t tell the congregation our struggles.
When we open by apologizing, we are subconsciously telling our audience that they shouldn’t listen, that it’s not a good sermon, or that they won’t miss much if they don’t pay attention. And if we tell the audience that we don’t think it’s a good sermon, many people will mentally check out.
Don’t give them that excuse. I’m not advocating that we should be boastful or deceptive. But just because we aren’t confident in our human abilities doesn’t mean that it’s not the exact message God wanted us to preach.
4. DON’T preach all doctrine, no practice – This is an easy trap to fall into, especially if you preach exegetically. Many passages are full of rich wonderful doctrine (and its practical applications will come along in another 4 weeks). I suggest not waiting. A month down the road, many won’t remember the nuances of this week’s message, and this week, your people need something to hold onto.
Don’t assume that just because you’ve presented the doctrine well, the application will come naturally. It might for some, but most would benefit by having their pastor tell them where to focus their efforts. If writing applications doesn’t come easy, I suggest Daniel Doriani’s “Putting the Truth to Work”.
5. DON’T preach too long – Sure, we all know not to do this, and yet it’s so easy to do. You think of another illustration, or you want to repeat a point. Perhaps you started your conclusion before realizing that you forgot to say one of your favorite lines, so you double back. Bad idea!
When talking about sermon length, my typical response is, “I think pastors should take as much time as they absolutely need to preach the text well, and not a minute longer”. Sermons get better with editing, and we can often say something in 1 paragraph that’s 5 times as powerful as 5 paragraphs. Choose your words wisely, state your points succinctly, and take all the time you absolutely need – and not a minute more!
6. DON’T hit that pet peeve or hobby horse…again – It’s entirely appropriate that sermons reflect the pastor’s heart, so it’s understandable that certain topics will rise to the top more often than others. None of that is bad, but it can become bad if we don’t keep it in check.
Every pastor has certain topics that they care about greatly. Whether it’s loving your neighbor, living righteously, living radically, caring for the poor, the call the evangelize, or something else, all of these topics deserve to be preached regularly because they appear in the Bible regularly.
The problem is that sometimes, we see these ideas where they don’t exist. I once sat under a pastor who cared about social justice. I would have expected him to find social justice in some passages that I might miss it, but he found social justice in every passage. For 2 years, and preaching through a half dozen books of the Bible, every sermon was about social justice. That’s no good. A congregation can’t grow without a well rounded diet.
Worse, perhaps, is the pastor who is consumed with denouncing something in society. While it’s true that in America, we put too much emphasis on consumerism, we spend too much time focused on sports, we watch too many trashy tv shows, and pop music teaches all kinds of idolatry – if we talk about these thing every week, our audience will never hear us. They’ll learn to tune out these messages, saying “Here he goes again…”, and they won’t hear any other messages because they’re not being preached.
So go ahead and mention that hobby horse or pet peeve when the passage merits it, but when you have to shove it into the passage or your sermon, you’re better off leaving it alone.
7. DON’T forget to use illustrations – John Witherspoon, the puritan preacher and Princeton president once had a woman guest at his house. She was noticing his garden and commented that there were no flowers in it. He famously responded, “No madam, you’ll find no flowers in my garden, nor in my discourses.” In other words, he despised illustrations.
That attitude may have worked before the Revolutionary War when they still printed the pastor’s sermons in Monday’s newspaper, but for a listening audience, the absence of illustrations isn’t just boring, it’s actually confusing. Most people remember stories better than they remember random facts. They connect with stories. The fact is, it’s easier to relate to a story than to a theological outline.
It might be tempting (in light of #5) to cut out the illustrations. They take up time without furthering your train of thought. It’s unwise to cut them out completely, however. The stories and maxims are what makes sermons memorable, so they’re worth the time they take.
8. But DON’T use too many illustrations – I once heard a guest preacher who got up to the pulpit and proceeded to read email forwards for 25 minutes, and then concluded by saying, “As Christians, we should have a good sense of humor.” Needless to say, it wasn’t the most powerful sermon I ever heard.
While few pastors would take it to that extreme, I’ve heard many sermons that are full of illustrations and short on text. This is the exact opposite problem as the last one. We aren’t called to preach illustrations, and we’re not hired as stand-up comics. Illustrations serve a purpose when they’re illustrating a biblical point, but on their own, they don’t really mean anything or carry any weight.
So yes, use illustrations, but don’t ever let illustrations become the centerpiece of the sermon.
9. DON’T come to the pulpit unprepared – Sound familiar? The first item in this list talked about being unprepared because you shortcut your sermon prep mentally, but there’s another great danger – perhaps the greatest danger in preaching – and that’s being unprepared spiritually.
By the time you’ve spent a week wrestling with a text, researching its finer points, determining an outline and considering how to best present it, a pastor usually knows his topic inside and out. But if we only wrestle with how to present the text, we’ve missed the greatest joy of the job.
As pastors, it’s our profession to study God’s word, and let that word affect our spiritual lives throughout the week. If we’re preaching on pride, but we don’t examine our own hearts for pride, our sermons will ring hollow. If we’re preaching on priorities, but we haven’t been convicted ourselves, then it’s unlikely our sermons will convict anyone else. And no matter the topic, if we haven’t bathed our sermons in prayer, and if we’re not relying on the Holy Spirit to speak to our people, our efforts are in vain. Being a pastor doesn’t mean that you’re perfect, but it does mean that you pay more attention to the weekly sermon than any other parishioner. Make that intentional attention count in your own life as well as your words.